WAGYU ZINE日本語

A5 is not a score for flavour

The letter and the number measure different things. Once you can read a grade properly, you choose beef differently.

WAGYU ZINE editors2 min read

A knife slicing a marbled block of wagyu

The A is about yield

The A in A5 is the yield grade: what share of the carcass ends up as meat. A is above standard, B is standard and C is below. In the official formula, A means a yield score of 72 or higher.

So A or B matters to the people buying and butchering the carcass. It says nothing direct about taste. An A5 and a B5 have the same meat quality grade.

The 5 is the lowest of four scores

The number is the meat quality grade. Graders score four things from 1 to 5:

  • marbling
  • colour and brightness of the meat
  • firmness and texture
  • colour, lustre and quality of the fat

The final grade is not an average. It is the lowest of the four. A carcass that scores 5 for marbling and 4 for colour is a grade 4.

Marbling has twelve steps

Marbling is judged against the Beef Marbling Standard, or BMS, which runs from No. 1 to No. 12. Graders look at the cross-section of the loin, cut between the sixth and seventh ribs.

BMS Marbling grade
No. 8 to 12 5
No. 5 to 7 4
No. 3 to 4 3
No. 2 2
No. 1 1

Two cuts can both be “grade 5” and look very different: No. 8 and No. 12 are a long way apart. Move the slider in the lab below to see the range.

A grade cannot tell you what you like

Grading is a shared ruler for trading carcasses. It rates how the meat looks; it does not measure flavour or aroma on the plate. In recent years A5 has become the most common grade of all, so a 5 is no longer rare in itself.

Some people love heavy marbling. Others want the taste of lean meat. Choosing a grade 4 or 3 is not settling for less; it is choosing what you like. When you ask a shop for the grade, ask for the cut too, and how they would cook it.

Marbling lab

Marbling is judged on the twelve-step Beef Marbling Standard. Drag the slider from No. 1 to No. 12 to see the range.

Marbling grade5

This model illustrates the idea. It is not the official reference used by graders.